Myths & Misconceptions About Fungi

Myths & Misconceptions About Fungi
MidJourney Art

Fungi play pivotal roles in our ecosystem, health, and culture. Yet, as they weave their silent magic beneath our feet, they often bear the brunt of misunderstandings and tall tales.

In this section, we aim to untangle fact from fiction, shedding light on these intriguing organisms. Let’s embark on a mycological myth-busting journey!

Unearthing Mycophobia: The Fear of Fungi

Mycophobia, an irrational fear of fungi, particularly mushrooms, finds its roots in various cultural, historical, and personal experiences. Often, it's linked to the uncertainty of edible versus poisonous varieties.

However, while caution is necessary, understanding and appreciation can alleviate baseless fears. Fungi have been allies for millennia, aiding in everything from food fermentation to medicine production.

Debunking Deadly Myths

When it comes to wild mushrooms, old wives' tales are aplenty. Here, we debunk some potentially deadly myths:

Myth: Poisonous mushrooms turn a silver spoon or silver coins black

Truth: This ancient tale asserts that toxic mushrooms will blacken silver, providing a clear warning sign. However, this is more about chemistry than edibility. Many completely safe-to-eat mushrooms contain sulfur compounds that can react with silver, causing it to tarnish. It's important not to rely on this test, as it could lead you astray.

Myth: Touching a toxic mushroom can poison you

Truth: Generally, merely touching a poisonous mushroom isn't harmful. Our skin acts as a barrier, preventing most toxins from entering our system. However, there are exceptions. The fire coral mushroom, for instance, can cause skin irritations upon contact. Always wash your hands after handling unfamiliar mushrooms and avoid touching your face.

Myth: All white mushrooms are safe to eat

Truth: While many believe that white mushrooms are universally safe, this is a dangerous oversimplification. Some toxic mushrooms, like the destroying angel, are white. It's essential not to judge edibility based on color alone.

Myth: All mushrooms with a skirt (a ring around the stem) are edible

Truth: A ring or skirt on the stem is not a sure sign of a mushroom's safety. While many edible mushrooms have this feature, so do some highly toxic ones. It's just one characteristic among many that should be considered when identifying mushrooms.

Myth: Eating raw mushrooms is always safe

Truth: Mushrooms are made up of chitin, a substance humans find hard to digest. Some mushrooms, like Agaricus bisporus (the common button mushroom), contain small amounts of toxins that can be broken down upon cooking but may cause discomfort when consumed raw. Always ensure you're aware of the appropriate way to consume different mushroom varieties.

Myth: Mushrooms with bright colors are always poisonous

Truth: Bright colors in the natural world often serve as warnings, but this isn't a hard and fast rule for mushrooms. While some brightly colored mushrooms are toxic, others are completely safe to eat. Conversely, many harmful mushrooms are dull or earth-toned. Color alone is not a reliable indicator.

Myth: Cooking a poisonous mushroom makes it safe to eat

Truth: Cooking might break down some toxins in certain mushrooms, but it won't render all poisonous mushrooms safe. Some toxins are heat-stable and will remain harmful even after prolonged cooking. Always identify mushrooms accurately before consumption and don't rely on cooking to detoxify them.

Myth: If animals eat a mushroom, it's safe for humans too

Truth: Animals have different digestive systems and metabolic processes. What's safe for them might not be for humans. Some animals can safely consume mushrooms that would be deadly to humans. Relying on animal behavior to judge mushroom edibility is perilous.

Myth: Edible mushrooms can't grow next to poisonous ones

Truth: Nature doesn't segregate mushrooms by edibility. It's entirely possible (and common) for both edible and toxic mushrooms to grow side by side. Judging a mushroom's safety by its neighbors can lead to serious mistakes.

Myth: All puffballs (a type of mushroom) are safe to eat

Truth: While many puffballs are edible, not all are. Additionally, some young toxic mushrooms can resemble puffballs before they mature, leading to potential misidentification. As with all wild mushrooms, it's crucial to be certain of their identity before consumption.

Myth: If a wild mushroom looks familiar, it's safe to eat

Truth: Visual recognition alone is fraught with risks. Many edible mushrooms have toxic look-alikes that can lead to serious illness or death. Relying on memory or superficial features is dangerous. Always consult an expert or a reliable field guide when foraging wild mushrooms, and when in doubt, play it safe and avoid consumption.

Common Misconceptions

Fungi often lurk in the shadow of misconceptions. Let's shine a light on the truth behind some common fungal fallacies:

Myth: All fungi are mushrooms

Truth: While all mushrooms are fungi, not all fungi are mushrooms. The term "fungi" encompasses a vast kingdom of organisms, of which mushrooms are just the fruiting bodies of certain species.

Myth: Mushrooms can only grow in the dark

Truth: While some mushrooms prefer shaded environments, many species require light to grow and will even orient themselves towards it.

Myth: All fungi are harmful and cause diseases

Truth: While some fungi can cause diseases, many play beneficial roles, such as decomposing organic matter, forming symbiotic relationships with plants, or being used in food and medicine.

Myth: The biggest part of a mushroom is what we see above ground

Truth: What we typically identify as a "mushroom" is just the fruiting body, analogous to an apple on an apple tree. The vast majority of the fungus consists of a network of threads, called mycelium, which spread out beneath the ground or within its host substrate.

Myth: Fungi are plants

Truth: Fungi are not plants. They belong to their own kingdom and have distinct cellular and metabolic differences from plants.

Myth: Fungi are more like plants than animals

Truth: Surprisingly, fungi are more closely related to animals than they are to plants. Our shared ancestor with fungi is more recent than plants' ancestor with fungi.

Myth: Mushrooms can't grow on people or animals

Truth: While most mushrooms (the fruiting bodies of fungi) don't grow on animals, there are many fungi that can infect and live on both humans and animals, leading to various diseases.

Myth: Fungi can't grow in extreme conditions

Truth: Fungi are incredibly adaptable and can grow in a range of extreme environments, from the cold Arctic to the hot deserts, and even on the International Space Station!

Myth: Mushrooms pop up only after rain

Truth: While rain can create favorable conditions for many mushrooms, not all mushrooms require recent rainfall to appear. Some grow in dry conditions or have other specific environmental triggers.

Myth: Fungi don’t have genetic material (DNA)

Truth: Fungi, like all living organisms, contain DNA. It's this DNA that provides the instructions for the fungus's growth, development, and functioning.

Myth: Mushrooms have no nutritional value

Truth: Mushrooms can be a good source of vitamins, minerals, antioxidants, and dietary fiber. Different species have varied nutritional profiles, but many are rich in B vitamins, selenium, and other beneficial compounds.

Myth: All fungi reproduce through spores

Truth: While many fungi do reproduce via spores, some reproduce through other means, such as fragmentation or budding.

Myth: Fungi only grow in decaying matter

Truth: While many fungi are decomposers and thrive on decaying organic matter, others form symbiotic relationships with plants, and some can even be parasitic, infecting other organisms.

Myth: All molds are toxic and should be avoided at all costs

Truth: While some molds produce toxic compounds called mycotoxins, not all molds are harmful. Some are even beneficial and play crucial roles in food production, such as in the making of cheese or fermented foods.

Myth: Fungi can't help clean polluted environments

Truth: Some fungi can break down pollutants and heavy metals in a process called mycoremediation. They can play an essential role in environmental cleanup.

Myth: Yeast isn't a fungus

Truth: Yeast is indeed a type of fungus. It's used in many food production processes, including bread baking and alcohol fermentation.

Myth: Mushrooms only grow in cold climates

Truth: Mushrooms grow on every continent, including in tropical and arid regions. Their growth depends more on moisture availability than temperature alone.

Myth: Mushroom spores are invisible to the naked eye

Truth: While individual spores are tiny and often not visible without magnification, masses of spores, like those in a mushroom's gill or a puffball, can sometimes be seen without aid.

Myth: All fungi need oxygen to grow

Truth: While many fungi are aerobic and require oxygen, there are anaerobic fungi that can grow in environments devoid of oxygen, such as deep within animal guts.

Myth: All bracket fungi on trees indicate the tree is dying

Truth: While the presence of bracket fungi can indicate decay or disease in a tree, not all bracket fungi signify a dying tree. Some form symbiotic relationships without causing harm.

Myth: Fungi only decompose dead organic matter

Truth: While many fungi are saprophytic and decompose dead matter, others are parasitic or mutualistic, meaning they can live on or with other living organisms.

Myth: Cheese mold is a sign of spoilage and is dangerous

Truth: Some cheeses are intentionally inoculated with specific molds to give them flavor, texture, and character. While some molds on cheese can indicate spoilage, not all molds are harmful or unwanted.

Myth: All fungi are decomposers

Truth: Not all fungi are decomposers. Some form mutualistic relationships with plants (mycorrhizal fungi), some are pathogens, and others live in symbiosis with animals or other fungi.

Myth: Beer and bread yeast are the same thing

Truth: While both types of yeast are fungi and can be used interchangeably in some recipes, beer yeast (usually Saccharomyces cerevisiae) and bread yeast are selected for their specific roles and can have different properties and flavors.

Myth: Mushrooms need sunlight to grow

Truth: While sunlight can be beneficial for some mushrooms, especially for initiating fruiting, many mushrooms grow perfectly well in the absence of direct sunlight.

Myth: Humans have fully explored and understand all there is about fungi

Truth: The fungal kingdom is vast and diverse. While we have made significant strides in understanding fungi, many species remain undiscovered or poorly studied. There's still much to learn!

Myth: Only dark, damp places can harbor mold

Truth: While molds prefer humid and dark environments, they can grow in a wide range of conditions. This includes relatively dry or well-lit areas, especially if there's a food source available.

Mystical Mushrooms: Supernatural & Cultural Lore

Fungi have long been intertwined with myths, magic, and mysticism across various cultures. Let's explore how different societies perceive these enigmatic organisms.

Native Mysteries: Indigenous Insights into Fungi

For many indigenous tribes, fungi hold spiritual significance. Used in rituals, as medicine, or in folklore, mushrooms have been revered for their mystical properties and profound connection to nature.

From the Mazatec traditions of using Psilocybe mushrooms in spiritual ceremonies to the native myths that speak of mushrooms as gateways to other realms, fungi have a deeply embedded place in native lore.

Fabled Fungi: European Tales and Traditions

In European tales, mushrooms often form whimsical backgrounds. Many associate them with magical creatures, like fairies and gnomes, believing mushrooms to be their umbrellas or homes.

Such tales, while enchanting, often served as cautionary stories. The enchanting world of fungi, with its myriad forms and colors, has always fueled the European imagination.

Iconic Imagery: The Fly Agaric Mushroom

The Fly Agaric, with its red cap dotted with white, is iconic. This mushroom has inspired countless fairy tales and even popular culture, like Super Mario Brothers. But did you know it's also linked to Christmas traditions in some cultures? Some believe Siberian shamans delivered these mushrooms as gifts during winter solstice, inspiring Santa Claus's red and white attire!

However, while captivating, the Fly Agaric is psychoactive and can be toxic. It's a testament to how fungi can intertwine with our cultural narratives in intricate ways.

Fungi in Asian Traditions

In Asia, mushrooms like Reishi and Shiitake aren't just culinary delights but revered for their medicinal properties. They feature prominently in traditional tales, often symbolizing longevity and health.

From ancient texts that document their uses to legends that celebrate their powers, fungi are integral to the Asian cultural fabric.

"The Last of Us": Myths of Zombifying Cordyceps in Humans

"The Last of Us" brings us face-to-face with a dystopian world ravaged by a mutated Cordyceps fungus. While the storytelling is captivating, it's essential to separate the riveting fiction from biological fact. Let's dive in:

  • Host Specificity: Cordyceps fungi are highly specialized, each typically targeting a specific insect species or group. The leap from infecting insects to humans is an extraordinary biological improbability.
  • Human Immune Defense: Our immune system is a fortress, designed to ward off a myriad of pathogens, including fungi. The complexity of the human body presents a formidable challenge for any fungus attempting a takeover.
  • Environmental Needs: Cordyceps thrives under specific conditions, often preferring damp forest floors. The human body's environment is worlds apart from this fungal habitat.
  • Lack of Evidence: While some fungi can indeed afflict humans, there's no historical or medical record of Cordyceps turning its sights on us.
  • Cordyceps' Beneficial Side: Beyond the realm of fiction, Cordyceps, especially strains like Cordyceps sinensis, have been lauded for potential health benefits in traditional medicine, particularly in Asia.
  • Narrative Device: The enthralling plot of "The Last of Us" is a testament to the power of storytelling. However, it remains just that: a brilliantly crafted narrative, not a biological reality.

In conclusion, while the world of fiction can spark our imagination and draw us into thrilling dystopian futures, it's vital to remember the line between reality and storytelling. The Cordyceps fungi, in their myriad forms and species, have coexisted with their insect hosts for millions of years without any inclination or ability to target humans. As you enjoy the riveting tales from "The Last of Us," rest assured that the Cordyceps in your garden are merely nature's wonders, not agents of an impending apocalypse. Sleep easy, and let the magic of nature continue to inspire awe, not fear.

Next Up: Fungi and Biodiversity

Keen to dive deeper into the role of fungi in our global ecosystem? Head on to 1.6 Fungi and Biodiversity.

Amazon Storefront

Amazon Storefront

Our Amazon Storefront is a curated collection of products we recommend, hosted on Amazon. By purchasing through our storefront, you not only find quality mycology products but also support our website's growth through commissions we earn, enabling us to continue providing valuable content and recommendations.

Amazon Storefront

Stay connected
For any inquiries or assistance, feel free to reach out to us